Cinnamon Rolls
Classic Cinnamon Rolls
$5.50
Sweet treats, made with love
Cinnamon rolls, custom cakes, and fresh baked desserts, handcrafted in small batches for every celebration.
Browse the menu
Shop by Category
Cinnamon rolls, custom cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and gift boxes ready to share.
About Sugar N Shai
Comfort, joy, and a touch of homemade love.
Sugar N Shai is a bakery built on the belief that every sweet treat should bring comfort, joy, and a touch of homemade love. We specialize in freshly baked desserts made with high quality ingredients, creating flavors that remind customers of family gatherings, celebrations, and cherished memories.
From soft cinnamon rolls and decadent cakes to cookies, cupcakes, and seasonal specialties, every item is crafted with care and attention to detail. Our goal is to provide delicious baked goods along with a welcoming experience that makes every customer feel valued.
Whether you are celebrating a birthday, wedding, holiday, or simply satisfying a sweet craving, our bakery is dedicated to making every occasion a little sweeter. Every bite is made with love, every order is prepared with purpose, and every customer becomes part of our growing family.
Handcrafted
Quality ingredients
Small batch
20+
Treats on the menu
100%
Made to order
48h
Fresh baked prep
Myshai Penn
Owner and head baker
Meet the owner
Hi, I'm Myshai.
I started Sugar N Shai with a love for creating desserts that bring people together. Every treat is handcrafted in small batches with quality ingredients, creative flavors, and a lot of care.
“If it is not something I would proudly serve my own family, it does not leave my kitchen.”
Our team
The hands behind every batch
A small team with a big love for baking, working together to make your order feel personal.
Myshai Penn
Owner and Head Baker
Myshai leads every recipe, custom design, and order from start to finish, with a focus on flavor and detail.
Decorating Team
Cakes and Custom Designs
Our decorating hands bring themes to life with piping, florals, and finishing touches that match your celebration.
Events Support
Dessert Tables and Setup
From styling to setup, our events help makes sure your dessert table is ready and beautiful before guests arrive.
What we offer
Services made for every occasion
Sugar N Shai offers freshly baked desserts and custom treats made with quality ingredients and attention to detail, from everyday cravings to full celebration spreads.
Custom Cake Design
Layer cakes designed around your theme, colors, and flavors for birthdays, weddings, showers, and anniversaries.
Start a custom cakeSpecial Order Desserts
Cinnamon rolls, cupcakes, cookies, brownies, dessert bars, pastries, and seasonal specialties made fresh for you.
Browse the menuCustom Dessert Tables
Styled dessert spreads for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, anniversaries, and graduations, set up and ready for guests.
Plan your tableEvent Catering
Dessert catering matched to your theme, style, and guest count, planned together so every detail fits your day.
Ask about cateringGift Boxes
Beautifully packed assortments for birthdays, holidays, thank yous, and just because surprises, with a handwritten note.
Shop gift boxesConvenient Pickup
Choose a pickup window that works for you, and your treats are boxed fresh and ready right when you arrive.
Pickup details
Pricing
Simple pricing for every order
Starting prices to help you plan. Final pricing depends on size, flavors, and design details.
Everyday Treats
Fresh baked cookies, brownies, bars, cupcakes, and cinnamon rolls ready for pickup.
$3.25
per treat
- Baked fresh to order
- Single, half dozen, or dozen
- Mix and match flavors
- Two to three days notice
Celebration Cakes
Custom layer cakes designed around your theme, colors, and flavor choices.
$65
starting price
- Design consultation included
- Serves twelve to sixteen
- Custom flavors and fillings
- Five to seven days notice
Event Dessert Tables
A full styled dessert spread for weddings, showers, graduations, and parties.
$250
starting price
- Serves twenty five to forty
- Styling, stands, and setup
- Menu planned with you
- Two weeks notice preferred
Shop
The full menu
Baked fresh to order. Tax calculated at checkout, with pickup details confirmed by email.
No treats found. Try a different search term.
Customer reviews
Kind words from our family
A few notes from customers who trusted us with their celebrations.
The cinnamon rolls were still warm when I picked them up and my whole family went quiet at the table. That never happens.
Myshai designed my daughter birthday cake exactly the way we imagined it. It looked beautiful and tasted even better.
The dessert table for our baby shower was stunning. Guests kept asking who made everything, and the setup was effortless for us.
I ordered a gift box for a coworker and it arrived so beautifully packed. The cookies were soft and fresh, exactly as promised.
Add your treats to the cart and check out. Every order is confirmed by email with pickup and payment details.
Everyday treats need two to three days. Custom cakes need five to seven days, and dessert tables need about two weeks.
Email Myshai2411@gmail.com as soon as you can. If baking has not started, we are happy to update it.
Yes. Share your theme, colors, flavors, and guest count, and we will design a cake that matches your celebration.
Absolutely. Send inspiration photos and we will plan the design, flavors, and finishing details with you.
Yes. We create dessert tables and favors for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, anniversaries, and graduations.
We confirm a pickup window by email or text once your order is placed, so your treats are ready and fresh.
Local delivery is available by request for larger orders and events. Ask when you place your order.
Yes. Styling, stands, and setup are included so your table looks beautiful before guests arrive.
They are best within four days. Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for the softest texture.
Yes. Wrap treats individually and freeze for up to three months, then thaw on the counter before serving.
Everything is baked in a kitchen that handles wheat, dairy, eggs, and nuts. Allergen questions are always welcome.
Myshai Penn, the owner and head baker. Every order is prepared with care, creativity, and a lot of heart.
Yes. Gift boxes, corporate orders, and large celebrations are welcome. Share your date and headcount.
Email Myshai2411@gmail.com or call 870-327-1793. Every message is read and answered personally.
Orders
Add your treats to the cart and check out. Every order is confirmed by email with pickup and payment details.
Everyday treats need two to three days. Custom cakes need five to seven days, and dessert tables need about two weeks.
Email Myshai2411@gmail.com as soon as you can. If baking has not started, we are happy to update it.
Custom Orders
Yes. Share your theme, colors, flavors, and guest count, and we will design a cake that matches your celebration.
Absolutely. Send inspiration photos and we will plan the design, flavors, and finishing details with you.
Yes. We create dessert tables and favors for birthdays, weddings, baby showers, anniversaries, and graduations.
Pickup and Delivery
We confirm a pickup window by email or text once your order is placed, so your treats are ready and fresh.
Local delivery is available by request for larger orders and events. Ask when you place your order.
Yes. Styling, stands, and setup are included so your table looks beautiful before guests arrive.
Freshness and Storage
They are best within four days. Keep them in an airtight container at room temperature for the softest texture.
Yes. Wrap treats individually and freeze for up to three months, then thaw on the counter before serving.
Everything is baked in a kitchen that handles wheat, dairy, eggs, and nuts. Allergen questions are always welcome.
About
Myshai Penn, the owner and head baker. Every order is prepared with care, creativity, and a lot of heart.
Yes. Gift boxes, corporate orders, and large celebrations are welcome. Share your date and headcount.
Email Myshai2411@gmail.com or call 870-327-1793. Every message is read and answered personally.
let's make it sweet
Order something special.
Planning a celebration or craving a fresh batch? Send a note with your date and ideas, and Myshai will get right back to you.
Baked fresh to order
•
Pickup and local delivery